I used to believe I could spot a lie from a mile away. My mother, Nancy, raised me on straight lines and straight talk—keep your porch clean, your hair brushed, and your secrets buried so deep no one trips over them. At thirty-eight, I thought I had mastered that philosophy. I was a mother of two, a wife to a charming man, and the unofficial commander of our block’s neighborhood watch spreadsheet. My biggest weekly dilemma was whether tulips or daffodils would look better by the mailbox. Then Mr. Whitmore died, and with him went every certainty I had about who I was.

The morning after his funeral, I found a thick envelope in my mailbox with my name written in looping blue ink. Inside was a short letter telling me that something had been buried for forty years beneath his old apple tree—something I had the right to know. Against my husband Richie’s cautious concern, I went alone the next morning. The soil gave easily under my shovel, and soon I unearthed a rusted metal box. Inside was a